Jill Schildhouse's Media Insights and Assignments

Jill Schildhouse's Media Insights and Assignments

Share this post

Jill Schildhouse's Media Insights and Assignments
Jill Schildhouse's Media Insights and Assignments
Let's Talk About: A Real-Life Example of a Brilliant Way to Follow Up on a Pitch

Let's Talk About: A Real-Life Example of a Brilliant Way to Follow Up on a Pitch

Plus: I'll break down WHY this strategy works so well and how to do it for your clients!

Jill Schildhouse's avatar
Jill Schildhouse
Mar 13, 2023
∙ Paid
13

Share this post

Jill Schildhouse's Media Insights and Assignments
Jill Schildhouse's Media Insights and Assignments
Let's Talk About: A Real-Life Example of a Brilliant Way to Follow Up on a Pitch
13
Share

Happy Monday, everyone!

In my Ask Me Anything sessions and my consulting workshops and 1:1s, one of the most-asked questions from publicists is about follow-up etiquette: How long after the initial pitch to follow up, how often to follow up, where to follow up (omg never a phone call, please!) … but nobody ever asks me what to say in a follow-up.

And that’s odd, because this is actually the MOST important part of the follow-up strategy.

Most publicists simply send a message like:

  • “Circling back on this pitch to gauge your interest in a story!”

  • “Bringing this to the top of your inbox in case you missed it!”

  • “Following up! Any coverage opps?”

  • “Can we get an interview scheduled?”

  • “I wanted to remind you about … [inserts exact same pitch word for word again]”

But there’s a 95% chance a writer is going to delete those follow-up attempts.

So let’s dive into why that is, what strategy you should be using instead, and look at a real-life example of a publicist who totally nailed it!

Oh shoot, you’ve hit the paywall? These industry insights are a perk for paid subscribers! Upgrade now to read the rest and see what you’ve been missing, including full access to my archives of paid content and upcoming Ask Me Anything sessions.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Jill Schildhouse
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share