Hello, subscribers.
I’m not gonna sugar-coat it: Last week was ROUGH. We’ve been hearing about media layoffs left and right over the past few months, but the 7% staff reduction at Dotdash Meredith hit especially hard. Why?
First, I know several amazing editors who are now out of a job, which is heartbreaking. And it’s a shame, considering DDMP is the largest publisher in the country and should have the capital for staffing. Those teams already seemed to run quite lean. And most of those displaced editors have now been dumped into the freelance pool, so look for them there.
Second, several editors I work with regularly were part of that downsizing effort … and that means I’m now without contacts at the usual places I sell stories. I’m trying to let the dust settle and then figure out who’s still left at the handful of outlets I contribute to over there. It could take some time to see how this all plays out, who I can work with, who has budget (some DDMP editors are already tweeting they they won’t have budget til Q2!), etc.
(According to my intel: nobody on the performance marketing teams, aka the ecommerce/shopping teams, was let go … so leadership certainly see the value in those revenue-generating departments. I’m told the Brides team is still intact. TripSavvy lost several editors and I think the ultimate fate of that pub is questionable at this time, as did T+L on the print side. BHG lost their entire beauty vertical. That’s all I’ve heard so far.)
And finally, this is just another massive blow to the industry during a time when we’re already seriously struggling. If you’ve been paying attention to the chatGPT discussion of AI robots taking over writing, it’s not just a hypothetical scenario anymore. Check out my Tweet, which now has 155k views:
Yep, you read that right: BuzzFeed is now using AI to write content and for some horrifying reason that’s made their stock JUMP! But that’s not the only publishing company who’s moving forward with this technology. TMB’s CEO says they are also going to be experimenting with it.
But if you’ve been following headlines, CNET started using it, and then had to issue a bunch of corrections to articles because of robot errors. How embarrassing that they didn’t have anyone editing these pieces. Where’s the oversight? We’re just letting the robots run amok already?!
It’s hard not to feel worried about what this all means for the future of my profession — one that I’ve dedicated 23 years of my life to. I’ve been playing around with chatGPT over the last few weeks just to see what it’s capable of and it does some things rather well, like when I asked it to write this poem about all the media layoffs (it’s a long poem, so click my Tweet to read the whole thing):
That poem damn near broke my heart. It was beautifully written and evoked plenty of emotion. Stupid robot can write!
But it does other things terribly … I’ve caught it providing erroneous results on numerous occasions because it’ll pull from literally anything on the web (including random blogs that have zero credibility and were obviously never fact-checked). So beware, as CNET learned the hard way!
Will robots take over my job in the next 5-10 years? Maybe. I’m mostly worried about formulaic articles, like listicles, gift guides and shopping roundups, to be honest. Things that require interviews and personal experiences aren’t a concern. Everything else? Remains to be seen, but as this technology grows more sophisticated in the coming years, there will be more uses for it.
I do think that publications will end up making do with fewer and fewer writers over time, lowering those editorial budgets even more (which is almost hard to imagine) … but they WILL have to hire more editors to polish up the robot content + fact-checkers to ensure accuracy. So there may be a shift in the writer:editor ratio at many outlets.
There’s plenty of speculation that Google’s almighty algorithm will be dinging content created by AI technology, which should certainly dissuade major outlets from using it and tanking their search results. But who really knows if that’s the case? Google is coming out with its own AI, so why would it penalize its own creation?
We’ll continue to see how this technology unfolds and how it impacts staffing decisions across major media outlets … but for now, know this: Your friends in the media world are a bit scared, stressed and sad. The layoffs and tech takeover is a lot to deal with at once. And while I always try to focus on abundance and rarely slip into a scarcity mindset, this whole thing is incredibly unsettling. Especially with how quickly it all came to be last week.
So what does all of this mean for PR?
First, I just want you to be aware of this massive shift in the industry … it’s important to keep all of this in mind as you send pitches and follow ups (and if you aren’t getting responses, maybe your editor isn’t on staff anymore).
It’s also a good time to start educating your clients on what’s going on and how the industry is shifting so they can adjust their expectations.
Also, building and maintaining relationships with freelancers is going to be more crucial than ever before, because you can’t count on editors who have been with pubs for years and years to still be there down the road. I offer a Become a Journalist’s BFF: Networking and Relationship Management session … let me know if you’d like to sign up for a workshop!
And finally, you should start thinking about how this will affect how you do your job down the road. Will your pitches be read by robots instead of writers eventually? Will earned media be even harder to land? This industry could look very different in just a few short years.
I’m guessing you have questions/comments … so let’s chat about this. The comments section is open and I’ll be responding to everything. Should I host an Ask Me Anything about this topic ASAP?
Beyond that, scroll down to see what I need for upcoming assignments!
Jill
PS: You can find even more industry insights in my other Substack, which I team up with Nicole Pajer to compile each week! This week’s topic will be about networking, media events and desksides.
Got Affiliate Marketing Questions for 2023?
Let’s face it: Most publications require affiliate marketing for inclusion these days. Publicist Sarah Karger co-created a course called Ultimate Masterclass and Introduction to Affiliate Marketing for Publicists and it’ll answer ALL of your questions!
Pick My Brain: Book a Consulting Session
Nicole Pajer and I have teamed up for Top Tier Consulting, where we offer a variety of customized consulting packages for agencies and freelance publicists to help take your media hits to the next level. These include:
Pitch Perfecting Strategy Session: We’ll workshop your pitches and offer suggestions to help improve your open rate and coverage opps!
Become a Journalist’s BFF: Networking and Relationship Management Session: Highly successful publicists know that building long-term relationships with journalists is truly the gift that keeps on giving, so we’ll give you tips on how to meet new journalists, stay in touch and become their go-to source.
Hosting the Perfect Virtual and/or In-Person Media Event Session: You’ll learn the ins and outs of how to create a media event that journalists will A) Want to attend B) Will stay engaged at C) Will work into coverage.
Agency Q&A Session: You’ve got questions? We’ve got answers! Nothing is off-limits!
Press Package 101 Session: We’ll help you make your packages more enticing, while actually saving your clients money in the process. And we’ll discuss how to target the right audiences, how to handle post-delivery follow-ups, and more.
Press Trips Invites and Itineraries Session: The two most important aspects to pulling off a successful press trip is nailing your invites and itineraries — we will help guide you through both!
We’re excited about this new venture and look forward to helping you become even better at what you do. Visit our website to learn more about the services and sessions we provide — we’re looking forward to working with you!
Please Share this Newsletter With Your Colleagues
If you find this newsletter valuable, please click the share button below and send it to your colleagues …. I’m especially looking for more travel publicists, publicists who rep healthcare and wellness professionals (dietitians, doctors, mental health, etc.), and of course product-focused publicists too! The more, the merrier!
PR Job Opportunities
Bon Communications is looking for an Account Supervisor (5+ years experience) to join its team. With a small team of senior specialists and deep connections from coast-to-coast, Bon Comms delivers the expertise of a full-service PR agency to their impressive roster of chefs, bartenders, hotels, wine / spirit professionals, interior designers and more from all over the country. This team is Denver-based, but a remote candidate is a plus! If you're passionate about hospitality and lifestyle PR, please email Katie@boncomms.com to introduce yourself with a cover letter and resume.
You can always email these job opps to me at JillSchildhouse@gmail.com — but please use PR Job Opps as your subject line so I can find them easily!
***Recently Published Pieces***
(Thank you for your help!)
USA TODAY (My debut!): 10 Features to Look For When Buying a Security Camera
Business Insider: I’m a Cirque du Soleil Performer. I Grew Up in the Circus and Now I Travel the World with My Husband and Kids.
Reader’s Digest: 28 Beautiful Gifts for Your Wife That Say I Love You
TripSavvy: The Cheapest Islands in the World to Visit
Reader’s Digest: 7 Best Foundations for Mature Skin
Family Handyman: 6 Best Basement Odor Eliminators
Taste of Home: How to Cook Cabbage So It’s Less Gassy
Travel + Leisure: The 7 Best Laptops for Travel of 2023 (also got picked up on Yahoo)
TripSavvy: The 18 Most Beautiful Islands in the World
Business Insider: I Paid a Stylist $300 to Determine Which Colors Look Best on Me
Now, it's time to get the word out! When you and your clients share your coverage on social media, please be sure to tag my accounts: Instagram, Twitter and LinkedIn (and please connect with me yourselves!).
—— Current Editorial Needs ——
1. Franklin Prosperity Report: Luxury Travel for Less
Looking for seasoned travel agents or other pros to discuss ideas for how to enjoy the perks of luxury travel while spending less money. This could be for transportation (car rentals and airfare), accommodations, high-end activities like safaris and helicopter rides, etc.
Some questions I’d like to answer in this piece (this is just a starting point, so please feel free to think far beyond this!): Is it possible to travel in business class or first class at a lower rate? If so, are there search engines/aggregators to find good deals? Are there specialized travel agencies? Does it make sense to buy packages or is it cheaper to price everything separately?
Please send credentials AND commentary for luxury travel hacks on a budget. The more unique, the better their chances of inclusion.
Subject line: Travel Agent Luxury Hacks
Email: JillSchildhouse@gmail.com
Pitch by: EOD Thursday
2. Travel + Leisure: Best Portable Power Banks for Travel
Open to all categories: best budget, best wireless/Mag safe, best 2-in-1, best with wall plug, best with A/C outlet, best for fast charging, most compact, best solar, best for phones, best for tablets, best for laptops
Pitches must include the following details:
Dimensions
Weight
Capacity (in mAh)
Input ports (# and type)
Output ports (# and type)
Cons (if you don’t include 2 “areas of opportunity,” I’ll be forced to pull from angry online reviews!)
Subject line: T+L Portable Power Banks + Name of Brand
Email: JillSchildhouse@gmail.com
Pitch by: EOD tomorrow
More Useful Info
Agency-wide Substack subscriptions available: Want your entire agency to read my paywalled insights? Awesome! Just shoot me an email with how many publicists will need access to my paid newsletter and I’ll send you a custom quote (which includes a group discount, of course!).
Sponsorship opps: Do you have a course/book/conference/tool/service that you’d like to promote to the 4,000+ publicists who subscribe to my newsletter? Contact me today to discuss sponsorship opportunities!
Other journalist newsletters definitely worth subscribing to: Be sure to follow my trusted colleagues so you can stay up-to-date on their pitching needs: Alice Dubin, Bryce Gruber, Aly Walansky, and Nicole Pajer.
So heartbreaking to see these publications lay off their staff. Thank you for making us aware of it, so we can be cognizant in our outreach. You're a great writer, I'm rooting for you to find new places for your stories!
On the ChatGPT front, the marketing team at my brand relies on it SO much, and I hate it. They find they still have to re-write everything, so it makes sense that CNET always has to issue corrections. I agree with you that interviews and long form features will never be able to written effectively with AI.
Oh my gosh :/ This is heartbreaking.